A well-loved Manly bakery has lost its outdoor seating in Rialto Lane after safety concerns were raised about the narrow laneway, leaving thousands of locals frustrated by the decision.
From laneway charm to safety concerns
Since opening in 2018, Rollers Bakehouse has built a reputation for its croissants and colourful pastries, with many customers enjoying their coffee and food on stools and benches lining Rialto Lane. The café’s laneway setting became part of its identity, attracting as many as 600 people on weekends.
That setting came under scrutiny in December 2023, when a complaint raised safety concerns about trucks and trade vehicles navigating the narrow strip. Council staff later reported that 11 bollards separating pedestrians and vehicles in the lane had been struck by vehicles.
By July 2024, Rollers was allowed a nine-month trial to reinstate its outdoor furniture, but just a month later, the arrangement was revoked.
A split council and a failed motion
At the September 2025 meeting, Cr Vincent De Luca tried to overturn the earlier ruling, arguing no safety issues had been logged during the trial. He suggested a compromise that included a shared pedestrian-vehicle zone with traffic calming features such as speed humps and a strict 10km/h speed limit.
His motion failed, leaving the eatery without outdoor seating. Cr Candy Bingham stood by her opposition, saying the lane was designed as a service road and not as a dining space.
Community support and business frustration
Owner James Sideris said the claims of damaged bollards were misleading, noting the three in front of Rollers Bakehouse had not been affected. He argued the bakery’s success had contributed to the gentrification of the laneways, bringing investment and foot traffic into the area.
More than 3,700 people signed an online petition supporting Rollers’ right to maintain its outdoor dining, highlighting the role the café plays in Manly’s social life.
Outdoor seating in Rialto Lane had also been mentioned in the council’s My Place: Manly plan to boost visitor numbers. Despite that, officials voted against its continuation, leaving many residents disappointed at the loss of what they considered a community meeting spot.
What’s next for Rialto Lane?
The decision has raised broader questions about how Manly’s laneways are used and whether balancing safety and vibrancy is possible. The owner has said he remains open to negotiating a middle ground that would address liability concerns while allowing customers to continue using the outdoor space.
Published 19-Sept-2025
