A Manly cafe has criticised the hefty $21,000 yearly fee for outdoor dining, arguing that it stifles local business while other councils waive fees to support small businesses.
Local Cafe Questions Fee Structure
Market Lane Cafe, a popular spot in Manly, displayed a sign revealing the large fee required by the Northern Beaches Council for its outdoor seating, stirring community discussion about the fairness of the charge. The cafe noted that, in contrast, the City of Sydney has waived all outdoor dining fees until June 2025 to support local businesses.
According to Market Lane Cafe, a lower or waived fee structure in Manly could better encourage alfresco dining and benefit local businesses and patrons alike.
Northern Beaches local business owner Mandeep Singh echoed these sentiments, sharing the cafe’s post on social media. Mr Singh suggested that fees as high as $21,000 per year make it increasingly difficult for small businesses to recover from pandemic-era losses. He urged council to consider a more sustainable and supportive fee model, particularly as these local establishments are central to the community and economy.
Response to Criticism
Northern Beaches Mayor Sue Heins responded to the concerns, explaining that the outdoor dining fees are set based on valuations from an independent appraiser and are in line with similar fees charged by other metropolitan councils. She added that fees were waived during the height of COVID-19 to help struggling businesses but believes that a fee for outdoor commercial use of public land is now fair.
The fees include application costs, rental charges, and a security bond, which vary depending on the location’s size and proximity to high-traffic areas like Manly Beach.
Ms. Heins also expressed the necessity to find a balance between public access, the interests of ratepayers, and commercial activities, noting that fees can help achieve this. She emphasised that officials are receptive to proposals that bolster a thriving local economy.
Community Concerns and Café’s Struggles
Market Lane Cafe’s post shared that running a hospitality business in Manly comes with significant financial challenges beyond council fees, such as high rents and general overheads. Despite these hurdles, the café expressed appreciation for its loyal customers, saying that the “genuine connections” with the community make it worthwhile to continue operating in the area. This sentiment resonates with many local businesses in Manly, who feel that the rising costs of operation risk overshadowing their contributions to the neighbourhood’s charm and economy.
Published 6-Nov-2024
